
Two very different controversies exposed two different failure points in the same business system. One raises questions about the risks organizations identify before someone enters a partnership. The other raises questions about what happens after they are already inside it. Together, they make one thing clear: governance is much bigger than having a code of conduct.
Governance starts before the partnership
Ed Sheeran found himself in a complicated position after Macklemore was dropped from his U.S. tour and four other supporting acts subsequently withdrew. Sheeran said the decision came from the promoter, while the promoter cited venue restrictions. Industry experts also noted that major artists generally have substantial influence over creative decisions and supporting acts, even though promoters and venues control other important parts of the tour. (AP News)
That creates a bigger business question than who was right or wrong:
What guardrails were in place before the tour began, and who owned the reputational risk?
Macklemore’s public positions were not new. His advocacy around Palestinians and criticism of Israel had been public well before this particular conflict. (Reuters)
So was the potential for stakeholder conflict unknown, or was a known risk underestimated?
I have led campaigns where brands, especially enterprise brands, vet creators and celebrities before approaching them for partnerships.
The process can include reviewing public statements, prior controversies, audience fit, reputational risks, and potential conflicts with other stakeholders.
The purpose is not to find people who have never expressed an opinion.
It is to understand known risk before making the partnership decision.
I view the lineup for a headliner’s tour as an extension of the headliner’s brand. It has to fit, draw an audience, and make money.
But the Sheeran situation demonstrates why partnership governance becomes complicated. A major tour can involve the artist, supporting acts, promoter, venues, sponsors, insurers, and other commercial partners. Different stakeholders have different authority and different levels of risk.
Someone still has to own the guardrail check.
That means asking questions such as:
- What does existing controversy around a potential partner mean for everyone involved?
- What known positions or behaviors could create conflict with other stakeholders?
- How significant could the fallout become?
- What happens if the known risk becomes the main story?
- Who has final authority when stakeholders disagree?
- What happens if one party wants the relationship to continue and another does not?
This is selection governance, reputational governance, and decision-rights governance.
Selection governance answers: Who gets approved?
Reputational governance asks: What known risks come with approving them?
Decision-rights governance answers: Who has authority when those risks become real?
A partnership can be creatively aligned and still be operationally misaligned.
Governance does not stop after approval
The US Open shows the other side of the system.
The tournament roughly doubled its number of credentialed influencers as it increased creator participation and sought to expand interest in tennis. Some players welcomed the increased attention. Others complained when photography, videos, noise, and bright lights became distracting during matches. Chair umpires intervened in some situations. (AP News)
The creator strategy itself makes sense.
Creators can generate FOMO, introduce tennis to new audiences, and turn the event into content that travels well beyond the grounds.
But there is a difference between sustainable amplification and unwanted friction.
The latter creates governance headaches.
The US Open already had rules. Its Guest Code of Conduct prohibits disruptive behavior, entry into restricted areas, unauthorized commercial activity, and certain forms of recording. The policy also gives the USTA enforcement options ranging from ejection to bans from future events. (US Open)
That makes the business lesson more interesting.
Having rules is not the same as having governance that works.
A policy can exist on paper while gaps remain in communication, ownership, enforcement, or escalation.
Once creators enter an event, different governance questions begin:
Were expectations communicated clearly?
Did everyone understand where they could go and what they could do?
Who was responsible for intervening?
Were rules enforced consistently?
And what was the escalation process once content creation began affecting the core experience?
This is conduct governance.
The goal is not to prevent creators from creating content. The goal is to make sure the activity that creates value for one stakeholder does not reduce value for another.
At the US Open, the players are still the core product.
Creator content should amplify that experience, not compete with it.
Governance is a system, not a document
The two situations look very different, but together they show why governance needs multiple layers.
Selection governance: Who enters the ecosystem?
Reputational governance: What risks come with that decision?
Conduct governance: What rules apply after someone enters?
Decision-rights governance: Who has authority when stakeholders disagree?
Response governance: What happens when the problem becomes real?
Response governance may be the piece organizations think about least.
It answers the uncomfortable questions in advance.
Who intervenes?
Who communicates?
Who makes the final call?
What happens when enforcing one rule creates another reputational problem?
And who owns the consequences?
Good governance does not eliminate controversy. No system can predict every outcome.
It identifies foreseeable risk, sets expectations, assigns ownership, creates escalation paths, and determines how decisions will be made before everyone is reacting in public.
That is the difference between having guardrails and simply having rules.
Sustainable business outcomes must come from systems that protect the core experience and deliver value for everyone in the ecosystem.
Governance is what finds the gap before the audience does.
